Withhold – Unsaid = 24 Hour Rule

One of the several things that i am excited these days is the tiny Mutual Aid grant to fund the creation of a transparency group fingerbook*. This would cover how to start a group and what are some useful tools to work with.  Fingerbooks are typically less than 40 pages and 1/3 graphics and cartoons.  I am guessing this collection of tools has the potential to do as much for improving emotional communication between individuals in groups as the consensus model has done for collective decision making.

There are a pair of sister tools for voicing under expressed discordant emotions or judgements toward someone in your group.  The first tool is for when the unexpressed topic is hard to say and you might be fearful of the other persons immediate response to hearing it.

Withholds: If there is someone you are not communicating smoothly in your group you may have a withhold – a story you need to tell to this person to let you start communicating with them more openly and honestly.  There is a format to withholds which runs like this:

Hawina: Paxus, i have a withhold for you

Paxus: Okay, i am up to hear it

Hawina: [Explains the issue which she feels or believes is in our/her way, from her perspective.  The thing that she needs to explain to feel like their is a common understanding between us.  This is likely based on her interaction or observation of me where she felt judgemental or otherwise under expressed.]

Paxus: Thank you.

And then you wait.  If Hawina brings up something that is emotionally charged for her and she does not want to have to deal with my response for 24 hours, then this is the right tool.

Unsaids are for smaller disconnecting experiences where you can use the same format as above (saying “unsaid” in place of “withhold”), only you dont have to wait to talk about it.  If the person hearing the unsaid wants to discuss what happened that caused this distancing experience and you are up for having it right now.

So when you are working in a transparency group and you need to clear something with another person in the group,  then you need to chose which of these tools feel right.  If it will help you feel safe/relaxed/open enuf to express yourself more to have the issue not discussed for a day, then withhold away.  But if you are not feeling very worried about communicating about the disconnect, perhaps because it is so small or you are open to more talk immediately, for any of  many reasons,  then the Unsaid format is preferable.  What i have recently experience in my groups is given the option to respond to Unsaids, most listeners do not do so and just let the clearing statement stand uncommented on.

pretty image, wrong message

*Mutual Aid is the small grant program from the FEC.  We are only asking for $50 for the distribution of the physical transparency fingerbooks to the FEC communities, but what is more important is having an online copy of the fingerbook masters so people can print their own.  The larger part of this grants is for$350 is to subsidize travel to the communities conference of prospective Chubby Squirrels, esp families.

wonderful topic for another post – what is not on your profile?

and know when to maintain secrets and confidences

Tags: , ,

About paxus

a funologist, memeticist and revolutionary. Can be found in the vanity bin of Wikipedia and in locations of imminent calamity. buckle up, there is going to be some rough sledding.

4 responses to “Withhold – Unsaid = 24 Hour Rule”

  1. Jason Sharma says :

    Transparency group? This is a novel idea for me. I’m accustomed to the notion that people are simply told what they need to know, and no more. Perhaps because we tend to be socially awkward or secretive? It’s probably an unhealthy way of doing things too…

    • paxus says :

      What you tell people creates your relationship with them. If you are in a transparency group, your self revealing actions influence how you are seen and experienced. The more transparent you can be in your communication, the greater the leaves of intimacy and understanding you can have. That is the theory at least.

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: